Drona Mendenhall

Written by Drona Mendenhall

Modified & Updated: 13 Jul 2024

Camryn Rabideau

Reviewed by Camryn Rabideau

8-best-creamy-peanut-butter
Source: Epicurious.com

When it comes to choosing the best creamy peanut butter, there are so many options to consider. From taste to texture, each brand brings something different to the table. Whether you prefer a classic flavor or something with a hint of sweetness, there's a creamy peanut butter out there for everyone. In this article, we'll explore the 8 best creamy peanut butter brands on the market, so you can find the perfect one for your next snack or recipe.

Top Picks:

Overall Score: 7/10

Peanut Butter & Co. Old Fashioned Crunchy Peanut Butter is a non-GMO, gluten-free, and vegan product with no added sugar. It offers 8 grams of protein per serving and is great for breakfast, sandwiches, or recipes. Made with only USA grown peanuts, it is certified OU kosher. Customers praise its delicious taste, and the product is praised for its clean and simple ingredients. However, some reviewers noted issues with the texture and the presence of palm oil. Overall, it received a 4.3/5 customer rating.

Key Features

  • 8 grams of protein per serving
  • Great for breakfast, sandwiches, recipes or right from the jar
  • No added sugar, no cholesterol, no trans fats, no hydrogenated oil, no high fructose corn syrup
  • Non-GMO project verified, certified gluten-free, certified vegan, certified OU kosher, made with only USA grown peanuts

Specifications

  • Dimension: 4.90Lx3.10Wx3.10H
  • Size: 16 Ounce (Pack of 1)

Pros

  • High protein content
  • Great taste
  • Versatile usage

Cons

  • Texture issues
  • Presence of palm oil
  • Some reviewers found it overpriced

Peanut Butter & Co. Old Fashioned Crunchy Peanut Butter is a delicious and versatile product, suitable for various uses. While it has received praise for its taste and clean ingredients, the presence of palm oil and texture issues have been noted as drawbacks. Overall, it is a well-liked product with a 4.3/5 customer rating.

Overall Score: 7/10

Brewer's Best Peanut Butter Beer and Wine Fruit Flavoring is an all-natural flavoring for beer and wine made in the United States. It comes in a 4 oz bottle and has a clear color. Customers have found it to be a great addition to their homemade brews and mixed drinks, providing consistent and strong flavor. However, some have noted that the flavor can be quite concentrated and may not always match the authentic taste of the fruit it's supposed to represent.

Key Features

  • Natural Peanut Butter Flavoring
  • All Natural Flavoring for Beer and Wine
  • Country of Origin: United States

Specifications

  • Color: Clear
  • Dimension: 2.00Lx2.00Wx5.00H
  • Size: 4 oz

Pros

  • Consistent flavor
  • Strong concentrate
  • Great for beer and wine

Cons

  • Flavor may not match authentic taste
  • Can be quite concentrated

Brewer’s Best Peanut Butter Beer and Wine Fruit Flavoring is a fantastic addition for home brewers and mixologists. The strong and consistent flavor it provides makes it a go-to choice for many, although it’s important to note that the taste may not always match the authentic fruit flavor.

Overall Score: 7/10

Natural Way Peanut Butter is made with high quality olive oil instead of palm oil and hydrogenated oils, making it a better choice for health-conscious consumers. With no added sugars and low sodium, this peanut butter is suitable for a variety of diets. It has a creamy texture, a delightful taste, and is free from GMOs. However, some users have reported issues with plastic film found inside the jars, which could be a cause for concern.

Key Features

  • NATURAL: Made with olive oil, salt, and roasted peanuts
  • HIGH PROTEIN: 8 grams per serving
  • PLANT BASED: Suitable for high-protein, keto diets
  • NO PALM OIL: Free from palm oil
  • NON-GMO & GLUTEN FREE: Certified and verified

Specifications

  • Dimension: 4.00Lx4.00Wx3.50H
  • Size: 1 Pound (Pack of 1)

Pros

  • High quality olive oil
  • Creamy and delicious taste
  • Low sugar and low sodium
  • Suitable for high-protein, keto diets

Cons

  • Issues with plastic film found inside the jar
  • Some inconsistency with freshness seal

The Natural Way Olive Oil Peanut Butter offers a delicious and healthier alternative to traditional peanut butter. With high-quality ingredients and a delightful taste, it’s a great choice for health-conscious consumers. However, potential issues with the freshness seal and plastic film should be addressed by the manufacturer to ensure complete customer satisfaction.

Overall Score: 7/10

Enjoy the classic peanut butter spread made with a proprietary nut grinding method, Includes only two ingredients: Orangutan-friendly palm oil and Gluten-Free, Non-GMO Project Verified, Kosher, with a commitment to high-quality, responsibly sourced ingredients and a donation to support hunger relief, pollinators, sustainable packaging, and environmentally friendly office practices. Comes with 210 calories and 7 grams of protein per serving.

Key Features

  • Includes 28-Ounce Classic Peanut Butter Spread Jar
  • High-quality, responsibly sourced ingredients
  • Supports hunger relief, pollinators, and sustainable packaging
  • Available in 8 delicious almond butter flavors
  • Corporate social responsibility commitment
  • 210 calories and 7 grams of protein per serving

Specifications

  • Dimension: 3.52Lx3.52Wx5.47H
  • Size: 28 Ounce (Pack of 1)

Pros

  • High-quality ingredients
  • Responsibly sourced
  • Supports social responsibility causes
  • Lovely taste with a great consistency
  • No added salt for a healthier option

Cons

  • May require stirring despite 'no-stir' label
  • Lacks flavor for some users

JUSTIN’S Andy’s Playground is a high-quality, delicious, and responsibly sourced classic peanut butter spread that supports various social responsibility causes. While some users may find the need to stir the peanut butter inconvenient, the overall taste and healthy ingredients make it a great addition to any pantry.

Overall Score: 9/10

Hello! 365 Peanut Butter Recipes is the ultimate cookbook for anyone who loves peanut butter. From dark chocolate to diabetic cookies, this cookbook has something for everyone. With over 365 recipes, you'll never run out of delicious peanut butter treats to make. Whether you're a beginner or a seasoned chef, this cookbook is sure to inspire you to get creative in the kitchen. With easy-to-follow instructions and beautiful photos, this book is a must-have for any peanut butter lover. Get ready to indulge in the best peanut butter recipes ever!

Key Features

  • Over 365 Peanut Butter Recipes
  • Includes Dark Chocolate and Diabetic Cookies
  • Sugar Free Options Available

Specifications

  • N/A

Pros

  • Wide variety of peanut butter recipes
  • Great for beginners and experienced cooks
  • Easy-to-follow instructions
  • Beautiful photos

Cons

  • May not cater to those with nut allergies

Hello! 365 Peanut Butter Recipes is the ultimate cookbook for peanut butter enthusiasts. With an extensive collection of recipes, beautiful photos, and easy-to-follow instructions, this book is a valuable addition to any kitchen. Whether you’re craving classic peanut butter cookies or looking to explore new flavor combinations, this cookbook has something for everyone. The only downside is that it may not be suitable for individuals with nut allergies. Overall, this cookbook deserves a solid 9 out of 10 for its creativity, variety, and user-friendly design.

Overall Score: 8/10

This cookbook is a delightful collection of 250 peanut butter cookie recipes, perfect for beginners and seasoned bakers. With easy-to-follow instructions and a wide variety of recipes, this book is a must-have for anyone who loves baking and peanut butter!

Key Features

  • 250 peanut butter cookie recipes
  • Suitable for beginners
  • Easy-to-follow instructions

Specifications

  • Dimension: 8.00Lx0.30Wx10.00H

Pros

  • Wide variety of recipes
  • Clear instructions

Cons

  • May not include advanced techniques
  • No nutritional information

With its extensive collection of recipes and beginner-friendly approach, Hello! 250 Peanut Butter Cookie Recipes is a fantastic choice for anyone with a sweet tooth and a love for baking. While it may not cater to advanced bakers or provide nutritional information, the sheer number of recipes and clear instructions make it a valuable addition to any cookbook collection.

Overall Score: 6/10

Indulge in the rich and creamy taste of OliveNation Texas Peanut Butter Flavor Fountain. This premium quality flavor fountain is perfect for adding the delicious flavor of peanut butter to a variety of recipes. It is water-soluble, kosher certified, gluten-free, sugar-free, and low in calories, making it a versatile ingredient for homemade frozen treats, beverages, and baked goods. With a 16 Fl Oz size, OliveNation's Texas Peanut Butter Flavor Fountain is the perfect addition to your kitchen pantry for creating tasty and delightful treats.

Key Features

  • Use as substitute for bakery emulsion
  • Rich, creamy texture
  • Water-soluble, kosher certified, gluten-free, sugar-free
  • Adds flavor to homemade frozen treats and beverages

Specifications

  • Size: 16 Fl Oz

Pros

  • Kosher certified and gluten-free
  • Low in calories
  • Versatile for a variety of recipes

Cons

  • May require larger amounts for strong flavor

OliveNation Texas Peanut Butter Flavor Fountain is a versatile and convenient product for adding the delicious taste of peanut butter to your homemade treats. While it may require using slightly larger amounts for a strong flavor, its kosher certification, gluten-free, sugar-free, and low-calorie features make it a valuable addition to any kitchen. Indulge in the rich and creamy goodness of this flavor fountain for a delightful culinary experience.

Overall Score: 8/10

Indulge in the delicious, creamy peanut butter flavor of REESE'S Peanut Butter Sauce. This multipurpose ingredient is perfect for baking peanut butter desserts, toppings, marinades, or drinks. Packed in a 4.5-pound bulk jar, this kosher sauce offers great value for creating birthday treats, holiday desserts, and more. With a creamy texture and irresistible taste, it's a must-have for all peanut butter lovers!

Key Features

  • Contains one (1) 4.5-pound bulk jar
  • Incorporate into best recipes for baking peanut butter treats
  • Kosher sauce packed in a bulk jar with twist-on, twist-off lid
  • Perfect for baked goods, toppings, marinades, pies, and shakes

Specifications

  • Dimension: 4.72Lx3.15Wx1.57H
  • Size: 4.5 Pound (Pack of 1)

Pros

  • Great for baking and toppings
  • Creamy and delicious peanut butter flavor

Cons

  • Texture is thinner than traditional peanut butter

For peanut butter enthusiasts, REESE’S Peanut Butter Sauce offers a delicious, creamy experience perfect for a variety of recipes and toppings. While it may have a thinner texture compared to traditional peanut butter, its irresistible taste and versatility make it a great addition to any pantry.

Best Peanut Butter Buyer's Guide

  • Types of Peanut Butter
    • Creamy: Smooth and easy to spread
    • Crunchy: Contains small pieces of peanuts for added texture
    • Natural: Made with just peanuts and sometimes a pinch of salt, with no added sugars or oils
    • Flavored: May contain added ingredients like chocolate or honey for extra taste
  • Ingredients to Look For
    • Peanuts: Look for a brand with high peanut content (90% or more)
    • No added sugars: Avoid brands with added sugars or sweeteners
    • No hydrogenated oils: Choose peanut butter without hydrogenated oils, which are unhealthy trans fats
    • Low sodium: Opt for a brand with low sodium content
  • Nutritional Information to Consider
    • Calories: Check the calorie content per serving
    • Protein: Look for a high protein content
    • Healthy fats: Choose peanut butter with high monounsaturated fats and low saturated fats
    • Fiber: Look for a brand with a good fiber content
  • Allergen Information
    • Peanut allergies: Check the label for a clear mention if the product may contain traces of other nuts
    • Gluten-free: Some brands are certified gluten-free, suitable for people with gluten intolerance
  • Packaging and Storage
    • Jar vs. plastic container: Consider your preference between glass jars and plastic containers
    • Refrigeration: Decide if you prefer storing your peanut butter in the fridge or at room temperature
    • Shelf life: Check the expiration date and choose a product with a longer shelf life if you don't consume peanut butter often
  • Brand Reputation
    • Reviews: Read customer reviews to gauge the overall satisfaction with the product
    • Brands with a good track record: Consider purchasing from established and reputable brands
  • Ethical Considerations
    • Sustainability: Some brands may prioritize sustainable sourcing and eco-friendly practices
    • Fair trade: Look for brands that support fair trade practices in their peanut sourcing
  • Budget
    • Price comparison: Compare prices per ounce or per serving to find a good value for your budget
    • Bulk options: Check if purchasing in bulk offers cost savings
  • Usage Preference
    • Cooking or baking: Consider how you plan to use the peanut butter, whether for spreading, cooking, or baking
    • Smoothies or shakes: Some peanut butter may be better suited for blending into smoothies
  • Personal Taste
    • Taste test: If possible, sample different brands to find one that aligns with your taste preferences
    • Texture: Consider whether you prefer a smooth or chunky texture
  • Availability
    • Local options: Check if there are locally made peanut butter brands available in your area
    • Online purchase: Consider if the preferred brand is available for convenient online purchase

Frequently Asked Questions about 8 Best Creamy Peanut Butter

What are the different types of peanut butter available in the market?

There are mainly three types of peanut butter available: smooth, crunchy, and organic. Smooth peanut butter is creamy and easy to spread, while crunchy peanut butter has pieces of peanuts in it. Organic peanut butter is made from all-natural ingredients without any additives or preservatives.

How is peanut butter made?

Peanut butter is made by grinding roasted peanuts into a paste. Sometimes, oil, sugar, and salt are added to the mixture to improve its taste and texture. The mixture is then blended until it reaches a smooth consistency.

Is peanut butter a healthy food option?

Peanut butter can be a healthy food option as it is a good source of protein, healthy fats, and important nutrients like potassium and magnesium. However, it is also high in calories and fat, so it should be consumed in moderation.

Can people with peanut allergies eat peanut butter?

People with peanut allergies should avoid eating peanut butter as it can trigger allergic reactions. There are other alternatives available, such as almond butter or sunflower seed butter, for those with peanut allergies.

How should peanut butter be stored?

Peanut butter should be stored in a cool, dry place and kept refrigerated after opening to prevent it from spoiling. It is important to check the expiration date and discard any peanut butter that has gone bad.

Was this page helpful?

Our commitment to delivering trustworthy and engaging content is at the heart of what we do. Each fact on our site is contributed by real users like you, bringing a wealth of diverse insights and information. To ensure the highest standards of accuracy and reliability, our dedicated editors meticulously review each submission. This process guarantees that the facts we share are not only fascinating but also credible. Trust in our commitment to quality and authenticity as you explore and learn with us.