Harri Haworth

Written by Harri Haworth

Modified & Updated: 20 May 2024

Sherman Smith

Reviewed by Sherman Smith

Source: Southernliving.com

Bentonville, Arkansas, is a city steeped in captivating local legends and folklore that have been passed down through generations. From mysterious tales of haunted landmarks to intriguing stories of legendary figures, the rich tapestry of Bentonville's folklore adds an enchanting layer to the city's cultural heritage. Exploring these local legends offers a unique glimpse into the traditions and beliefs that have shaped the community over time.

In this article, we'll delve into nine fascinating facts about the local legends and folklore in Bentonville, Arkansas. Each fact will unveil a different aspect of the city's folklore, shedding light on the captivating narratives that have captured the imaginations of residents and visitors alike. Join us as we embark on a journey through the enchanting realm of Bentonville's folklore, where history, mystery, and imagination intertwine to create a tapestry of captivating stories and enduring legends.

Key Takeaways:

  • Bentonville, Arkansas is steeped in captivating local legends and folklore, from the mysterious Bentonville Witch to the haunting Phantom Train, drawing in visitors and residents alike with its enchanting tales.
  • The legends of Bentonville, Arkansas, including the Ozark Howler and the Lost Silver Mine, add an air of mystery and adventure to the city, making it a fascinating destination for those seeking thrilling folklore and mythical tales.
Table of Contents

The Legend of the Bentonville Witch

Nestled in the heart of Bentonville, Arkansas, is the age-old legend of the Bentonville Witch. According to local folklore, the spirit of a powerful witch is said to roam the woods surrounding the city, casting spells and protecting the natural beauty of the area. The tale of the Bentonville Witch has been passed down through generations, captivating the imaginations of residents and visitors alike. Many claim to have encountered mysterious occurrences in the woods, attributing them to the mystical presence of the Bentonville Witch.

The Haunted Hollows of Sugar Creek

Deep within the lush forests of Bentonville lies Sugar Creek, a place shrouded in eerie tales and spine-chilling legends. Local folklore speaks of ghostly apparitions and unexplained phenomena haunting the hollows of Sugar Creek. Stories of lost souls and spectral sightings have fueled the mystique surrounding this enigmatic locale, drawing thrill-seekers and curious explorers to uncover the secrets hidden within its shadowy depths.

The Enigmatic Phantom of Crystal Bridges

Crystal Bridges, renowned for its world-class art collection, is also steeped in a lesser-known legend. Whispers of a spectral presence haunting the museum's corridors have circulated among staff and visitors. Tales of unexplained footsteps, flickering lights, and ghostly apparitions have given rise to the belief that the spirit of a former artist may still wander the hallowed halls of Crystal Bridges, eternally bound to the masterpieces within.

The Mysterious Lights of Tanyard Creek

In the quiet outskirts of Bentonville, the legend of the Tanyard Creek Lights continues to intrigue and bewilder locals and tourists alike. As dusk descends, ethereal lights are said to materialize along the creek, dancing and flickering in the darkness. The origin of these mysterious lights remains a subject of speculation, with some attributing them to supernatural forces, while others seek a scientific explanation for this captivating phenomenon.

The Tale of the Ozark Howler

Deep within the dense forests of the Ozarks, a fearsome legend looms large—the Ozark Howler. Described as a creature with piercing red eyes and a bone-chilling howl, this mythical beast has been the subject of countless stories and folklore in Bentonville. The enigmatic nature of the Ozark Howler continues to fuel the imagination of locals, who regale visitors with tales of encounters and sightings of this elusive and terrifying entity.

The Legend of the Lost Silver Mine

Bentonville's rich tapestry of folklore includes the enduring legend of the Lost Silver Mine, a fabled treasure trove hidden within the rugged terrain of the Ozark Mountains. As the story goes, intrepid explorers have long sought the elusive mine, said to be guarded by spectral sentinels and cloaked in mystical enchantments. The allure of discovering this fabled fortune has beckoned adventurers to venture into the untamed wilderness, braving the unknown in pursuit of untold riches.

The Ghostly Guardians of War Eagle Mill

Amidst the tranquil beauty of War Eagle Mill, whispers of ghostly guardians and spectral millers have woven a haunting narrative into the fabric of local folklore. Visitors to the historic site have reported encounters with ethereal figures and unexplained phenomena, adding to the mystique that enshrouds the mill. The tales of these ghostly guardians serve as a testament to the enduring legacy of War Eagle Mill and its spectral inhabitants.

The Enchanted Waters of Lake Bella Vista

Lake Bella Vista, with its serene waters and picturesque surroundings, is steeped in a mystical legend that has captivated the imagination of Bentonville's residents. According to local folklore, the lake is said to be enchanted, with whispers of mystical creatures and otherworldly guardians dwelling beneath its tranquil surface. The allure of this enchanting tale continues to draw visitors to the shores of Lake Bella Vista, where the line between reality and myth becomes beautifully blurred.

The Fabled Phantom Train of Bentonville

The legend of the Phantom Train of Bentonville has echoed through the annals of local folklore, weaving a tale of spectral locomotives and ghostly apparitions. As the story goes, a phantom train is said to materialize on moonlit nights, hurtling through the spectral mists with an otherworldly glow. The haunting sound of its whistle and the ethereal sight of its passage have left an indelible mark on the collective imagination of Bentonville, perpetuating the enduring legend of the Phantom Train.


Bentonville, Arkansas, is steeped in captivating local legends and folklore that have been passed down through generations. From the mysterious lights of the Tilly Willy Bridge to the haunting tales of the Bentonville Witch, the city's folklore adds an intriguing layer to its rich history. Exploring these stories not only offers a glimpse into the past but also provides a unique way to connect with the community and its heritage. Whether you're a local resident or a visitor, delving into Bentonville's local legends and folklore promises an unforgettable journey through time and imagination.


What are some popular local legends in Bentonville, Arkansas?Bentonville, Arkansas, boasts several popular local legends, including the mysterious lights of the Tilly Willy Bridge and the haunting tales of the Bentonville Witch. These stories have been passed down through generations, adding a captivating layer to the city's folklore.

Are there any guided tours or events related to Bentonville's local legends and folklore?Yes, there are guided tours and events that delve into Bentonville's local legends and folklore. These experiences offer an immersive journey into the city's rich history and provide an opportunity to explore the captivating stories that have shaped Bentonville's cultural tapestry.

Was this page helpful?

Our commitment to delivering trustworthy and engaging content is at the heart of what we do. Each fact on our site is contributed by real users like you, bringing a wealth of diverse insights and information. To ensure the highest standards of accuracy and reliability, our dedicated editors meticulously review each submission. This process guarantees that the facts we share are not only fascinating but also credible. Trust in our commitment to quality and authenticity as you explore and learn with us.