Alisun Pinckney

Written by Alisun Pinckney

Published: 04 Jan 2025

37-facts-about-alferd-packer
Source: Colorado.edu

Who was Alferd Packer? Alferd Packer, a name that sends shivers down the spine, was an American prospector known for his infamous tale of survival and cannibalism. In the winter of 1874, Packer led a group of men through the treacherous San Juan Mountains in Colorado. When the group got lost and supplies ran out, Packer resorted to eating his fellow travelers to stay alive. He was later tried and convicted for his gruesome actions. Despite his dark legacy, Packer's story remains a chilling chapter in American history, blending elements of survival, desperation, and the macabre.

Key Takeaways:

  • Alferd Packer, a controversial figure in American history, survived a harrowing journey and faced a sensational trial, leaving behind a legacy of fascination and ethical debate.
  • His story of survival and cannibalism continues to captivate audiences, sparking discussions about morality, human nature, and the unpredictability of nature.
Table of Contents

Alferd Packer: The Man Behind the Legend

Alferd Packer, a name that echoes through the annals of American history, is often remembered for his infamous tale of survival and cannibalism. His story is filled with twists, turns, and a fair share of controversy. Let's dive into some fascinating facts about this enigmatic figure.

  1. Alferd Packer was born on January 21, 1842, in Allegheny County, Pennsylvania. His early life was relatively uneventful, growing up in a modest family.

  2. He served in the Union Army during the Civil War. Packer enlisted twice, but both times he was discharged due to epilepsy.

  3. Packer's name is often misspelled as "Alfred." The correct spelling, "Alferd," was reportedly a result of a tattoo artist's mistake.

  4. In 1873, Packer joined a group of prospectors heading to the Colorado gold fields. This journey would become the backdrop for his infamous tale.

  5. The group got lost in the San Juan Mountains during a harsh winter. They ran out of food and faced extreme conditions.

  6. Packer was the sole survivor of the expedition. He claimed that his companions had died from starvation and exposure.

  7. He confessed to cannibalism to survive. Packer admitted to eating the flesh of his dead companions to stay alive.

  8. Packer was arrested in 1874 but escaped from jail. He remained a fugitive for nine years.

  9. He was recaptured in 1883 in Wyoming. Packer was then brought back to Colorado to stand trial.

  10. Packer was convicted of manslaughter in 1883. He was sentenced to 40 years in prison, the longest sentence for manslaughter at the time.

The Trial and Aftermath

The trial of Alferd Packer was a sensational event, drawing significant public attention. His story continued to evolve, with new details emerging over time.

  1. Packer's trial was held in Lake City, Colorado. It was one of the most talked-about trials of the 19th century.

  2. He maintained his innocence regarding murder. Packer insisted that he only killed in self-defense.

  3. The judge reportedly said, "There was seven Democrats in Hinsdale County, but you, yah voracious, man-eatin' son of a bitch, yah et five of 'em!" This quote, though likely apocryphal, highlights the sensational nature of the trial.

  4. Packer's sentence was later reduced. In 1901, his sentence was commuted, and he was released on parole.

  5. He spent his final years in Littleton, Colorado. Packer lived a relatively quiet life after his release.

  6. Packer died on April 23, 1907. He was buried in Littleton Cemetery.

  7. His grave is a popular tourist attraction. Visitors often leave coins and other tokens on his headstone.

  8. Packer's story inspired numerous books and films. His tale of survival and cannibalism continues to captivate audiences.

The Legacy of Alferd Packer

Alferd Packer's legacy is a mix of infamy and fascination. His story has left an indelible mark on American folklore and history.

  1. The University of Colorado Boulder named a cafeteria after him. The Alferd Packer Restaurant & Grill is a nod to his infamous tale.

  2. Packer's story is often referenced in popular culture. He has been mentioned in songs, movies, and TV shows.

  3. A musical comedy titled "Cannibal! The Musical" was created about his life. Trey Parker, co-creator of South Park, wrote and directed the film.

  4. Packer's case is studied in criminology courses. His story provides insights into survival psychology and criminal justice.

  5. There are annual Alferd Packer Days in Lake City, Colorado. These events commemorate the trial and the legend of Packer.

  6. Packer's story raises ethical questions about survival. His actions continue to spark debates about morality and human nature.

  7. Some believe Packer was innocent of murder. Various theories suggest he was wrongfully convicted.

  8. Packer's tale is a cautionary story about wilderness survival. It highlights the dangers and unpredictability of nature.

  9. His story has been compared to other survival tales. Packer's experience is often juxtaposed with stories like the Donner Party.

Controversies and Theories

Alferd Packer's story is shrouded in controversy and speculation. Various theories have emerged over the years, adding layers to his already complex narrative.

  1. Some historians believe Packer was a victim of circumstance. They argue that he did what he had to do to survive.

  2. Others think he was a cold-blooded murderer. This theory suggests he killed his companions for their supplies.

  3. Packer's own accounts were inconsistent. His story changed multiple times, leading to further confusion.

  4. Forensic evidence has been re-examined. Modern techniques have provided new insights into the case.

  5. Packer's trial was marred by legal irregularities. Some argue that he didn't receive a fair trial.

  6. There are claims of hidden gold. Some believe Packer and his group were carrying gold that was never found.

  7. Packer's mental state has been questioned. His epilepsy and possible PTSD may have influenced his actions.

  8. The exact location of the campsite remains unknown. Despite numerous searches, the site where Packer's companions died has never been definitively identified.

  9. Packer's story has been romanticized over time. The legend often overshadows the grim reality of his experience.

  10. His tale continues to be a subject of fascination. Alferd Packer's story remains a compelling chapter in American history.

The Legacy of Alferd Packer

Alferd Packer's story is one of the most bizarre and chilling tales in American history. From his mysterious journey through the Colorado mountains to the gruesome accusations of cannibalism, Packer's life has fascinated and horrified people for over a century. His trial and subsequent imprisonment raised questions about survival, morality, and justice. Even today, Packer's name evokes curiosity and debate. Whether viewed as a desperate survivor or a cold-blooded murderer, his legacy endures in folklore, books, and even pop culture. The facts surrounding his life and crimes remind us of the thin line between civilization and savagery. As we reflect on Packer's tale, we're reminded of the complexities of human nature and the extreme lengths to which people might go when faced with life-or-death situations.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did Alferd Packer do to become famous?
Alferd Packer grabbed headlines for being the only person in U.S. history convicted of cannibalism. His story unfolds in the winter of 1874, when he and five others tried to traverse the Colorado Rockies. Weeks later, Packer emerged alone, eventually confessing to consuming his travel companions to survive.
How did Alferd Packer's trial unfold?
Packer's trial was a spectacle, filled with twists and turns. Initially, he faced a death sentence, but due to legal technicalities, his conviction was overturned. At a second trial, he received a 40-year sentence, which was quite severe for the time, reflecting the public's shock and horror at his actions.
Was there any truth to Alferd Packer's story of survival?
Yes, parts of Packer's harrowing tale of survival were corroborated by evidence. Forensic analysis of the campsite years later did confirm human remains with signs consistent with Packer's account of starvation and desperate measures for survival.
Did Alferd Packer ever express remorse for his actions?
Reports vary on this matter. Some accounts suggest Packer showed remorse, particularly in his later years, reflecting on the dire circumstances that led to his unthinkable actions. However, detailed records of his expressions of guilt or remorse are scarce, leaving some aspects of his emotional state a mystery.
How did Alferd Packer spend his final years?
After serving 18 years of his sentence, Packer was paroled due to good behavior and health concerns. He lived a relatively quiet life afterward, working as a guard at The Denver Post and later as a ranch hand. Packer passed away in 1907, leaving behind a legacy that continues to fascinate and horrify.
Is Alferd Packer's story still remembered today?
Absolutely, Packer's tale has not faded into obscurity. It has inspired books, films, and even a musical, showcasing the enduring fascination with his life and the gruesome events of 1874. Additionally, historical sites and museums in Colorado still recount his story, drawing visitors intrigued by this dark chapter in American history.
Can visitors explore places related to Alferd Packer's journey?
Yes, history buffs can visit several sites in Colorado connected to Packer's infamous journey. These include the location of his trial, his burial site, and the area where the tragic events took place, now marked with memorials and informational plaques. These sites offer a tangible connection to the past, allowing visitors to reflect on the complexities of survival and human nature.

Was this page helpful?

Our commitment to delivering trustworthy and engaging content is at the heart of what we do. Each fact on our site is contributed by real users like you, bringing a wealth of diverse insights and information. To ensure the highest standards of accuracy and reliability, our dedicated editors meticulously review each submission. This process guarantees that the facts we share are not only fascinating but also credible. Trust in our commitment to quality and authenticity as you explore and learn with us.