Deborah Steinmetz

Written by Deborah Steinmetz

Published: 01 Oct 2025

25-facts-about-columbus-crew-vs-new-york-city-fc
Source: Youtube.com

Who will come out on top when Columbus Crew faces New York City FC? This matchup promises excitement, drama, and plenty of action. Both teams have a rich history and passionate fanbases. Columbus Crew, known for their resilience and tactical prowess, will clash with New York City FC, a team celebrated for their flair and attacking style. What makes this rivalry so thrilling? From memorable goals to nail-biting finishes, every encounter between these two teams adds a new chapter to their storied rivalry. Ready to dive into 25 fascinating facts about Columbus Crew vs New York City FC? Buckle up, because this is going to be a thrilling ride through the highs, lows, and unforgettable moments of this epic showdown.

Table of Contents

Columbus Crew: A Storied History

Columbus Crew, one of Major League Soccer's (MLS) original teams, has a rich history filled with memorable moments and achievements. Let's dive into some fascinating facts about this iconic team.

  1. Founding Member: Columbus Crew was one of the ten charter clubs of MLS, established in 1994 and began playing in 1996.

  2. First Soccer-Specific Stadium: Crew Stadium, now known as Historic Crew Stadium, was the first soccer-specific stadium in the United States, opening in 1999.

  3. Championship Glory: Columbus Crew won their first MLS Cup in 2008, defeating the New York Red Bulls 3-1.

  4. Supporter Culture: The Nordecke, a portmanteau of the German words for "north" and "corner," is the dedicated supporters' section known for its passionate fans and vibrant atmosphere.

  5. Rebranding: In 2021, the team underwent a rebranding, changing their name to Columbus SC, but reverted to Columbus Crew after fan backlash.

  6. Stadium Move: In 2021, the Crew moved to the new Lower.com Field, a state-of-the-art stadium located in downtown Columbus.

  7. Notable Players: Legendary players like Brian McBride, Guillermo Barros Schelotto, and Federico Higuaín have donned the Crew jersey.

  8. Youth Development: The Crew Academy has produced several homegrown talents, including Wil Trapp and Aidan Morris.

  9. Rivalries: The Crew's main rivalries include matches against FC Cincinnati, known as the "Hell is Real" derby, and the Chicago Fire.

  10. Community Involvement: The Crew is deeply involved in the Columbus community, with numerous outreach programs and charitable initiatives.

New York City FC: The New Kids on the Block

New York City FC (NYCFC) may be a newer addition to MLS, but they have quickly made a name for themselves. Here are some intriguing facts about NYCFC.

  1. Inception: NYCFC was announced as the 20th MLS franchise in 2013 and began playing in 2015.

  2. City Football Group: The team is owned by City Football Group, which also owns Manchester City, and the New York Yankees.

  3. Yankee Stadium: NYCFC plays its home games at Yankee Stadium, a unique venue for soccer.

  4. First Signing: Spanish legend David Villa was NYCFC's first-ever player signing and served as the team's captain.

  5. Playoff Success: NYCFC made the playoffs in their second season and have been consistent contenders since.

  6. First Trophy: NYCFC won their first major trophy, the MLS Cup, in 2021, defeating the Portland Timbers in a dramatic penalty shootout.

  7. Youth Academy: NYCFC's academy has quickly become one of the best in the league, producing talents like James Sands and Gio Reyna.

  8. Rivalries: NYCFC's main rivalry is with the New York Red Bulls, known as the Hudson River Derby.

  9. Fan Base: The team has a passionate and diverse fan base, with supporters' groups like The Third Rail leading the charge.

  10. Community Efforts: NYCFC is committed to community service, with initiatives like City in the Community (CITC) focusing on youth development and social inclusion.

Columbus Crew vs. New York City FC: Head-to-Head

When these two teams face off, it's always an exciting match. Here are some key facts about their head-to-head encounters.

  1. First Meeting: The first match between Columbus Crew and NYCFC took place on July 29, 2015, ending in a 2-2 draw.

  2. Overall Record: As of 2023, Columbus Crew and NYCFC have faced each other 20 times, with Columbus winning 8, NYCFC winning 7, and 5 matches ending in a draw.

  3. High-Scoring Games: Their matches often feature plenty of goals, with an average of 3 goals per game.

  4. Playoff Battles: The two teams have met in the playoffs twice, with Columbus winning both encounters in 2017 and 2020.

  5. Memorable Moments: One of the most memorable matches was in 2017 when Columbus Crew defeated NYCFC 4-1 in the first leg of the Eastern Conference Semifinals, setting the stage for their playoff success.

The Final Whistle

Columbus Crew vs New York City FC matches always bring excitement. From their first clash to recent battles, these teams have shown why MLS is thrilling. Columbus Crew, with their rich history and passionate fans, often bring their A-game. New York City FC, a newer team, has quickly made a name for themselves with strong performances and star players.

Both teams have had memorable moments, like Columbus Crew's 2020 MLS Cup win and NYCFC's impressive playoff runs. Their head-to-head stats show a balanced rivalry, making each match unpredictable. Fans eagerly await each encounter, knowing anything can happen.

Whether you're a die-hard supporter or a casual viewer, these matches never disappoint. The rivalry continues to grow, promising more unforgettable moments. So, next time Columbus Crew faces New York City FC, grab your scarf, cheer loud, and enjoy the beautiful game.

Was this page helpful?

Our commitment to delivering trustworthy and engaging content is at the heart of what we do. Each fact on our site is contributed by real users like you, bringing a wealth of diverse insights and information. To ensure the highest standards of accuracy and reliability, our dedicated editors meticulously review each submission. This process guarantees that the facts we share are not only fascinating but also credible. Trust in our commitment to quality and authenticity as you explore and learn with us.